Download E-books Aristotle on False Reasoning: Language and the World in the Sophistical Refutations (Suny Series in Ancient Greek Philosophy) PDF

By Scott G. Schreiber

Providing the 1st book-length examine in English of Aristotle s Sophistical Refutations, this paintings takes a clean examine this seminal textual content on fake reasoning. via a cautious and significant research of Aristotle s examples of sophistical reasoning, Scott G. Schreiber explores Aristotle s reason for his taxonomy of twelve fallacy varieties. opposite to yes sleek makes an attempt to minimize all flawed reasoning to both error of logical shape or linguistic imprecision, Aristotle insists that, as very important as shape and language are, particular types of fake reasoning derive their persuasiveness from unsuitable ideals concerning the nature of language and the character of the world."

Show description

Read Online or Download Aristotle on False Reasoning: Language and the World in the Sophistical Refutations (Suny Series in Ancient Greek Philosophy) PDF

Similar Ancient Greece books

Ancient Greece (Collins Gem)

From theatre to politics, no different unmarried civilisation has stimulated the Western global extra profoundly than that of historical Greece. From the roots of democracy to philosophy and arithmetic, it’s attention-grabbing to profit how a lot western civilisation has stemmed from that of old Greece. This e-book bargains an creation to the lives of the traditional Greeks, their mythologies and traditions and their tradition and studying.

Electra and Other Plays (Penguin Classics)

4 seminal tragedies by way of the grasp Greek dramatist, in gleaming new translationsOf the a couple of hundred performs Sophocles wrote over the process his lengthy lifestyles, merely seven live to tell the tale. This quantity collects 4 of them, all newly translated. Electra portrays the grief of a tender lady for her father, Agamemnon, who has been killed by way of her mother's lover.

The Persians and Other Plays (Penguin Classics)

Aeschylus (525-456 BC) introduced a brand new grandeur and epic sweep to the drama of classical Athens, elevating it to the prestige of excessive paintings. The Persians, the single Greek tragedy to house occasions from contemporary Athenian background, depicts the ultimate defeat of Persia within the conflict of Salamis, throughout the eyes of the Persian courtroom of King Xerxes, changing into a sad lesson in tyranny.

The Penguin Historical Atlas of Ancient Greece

The cradle of Western civilisation, old Greece was once a land of contradictions and clash. Intensely quarrelsome and aggressive, the Greek city-states always proved unwilling and not able to unite. but, even with or maybe due to this inner discord, no historical civilization proved so dynamic or effective.

Additional resources for Aristotle on False Reasoning: Language and the World in the Sophistical Refutations (Suny Series in Ancient Greek Philosophy)

Show sample text content

Aristotle has no longer quoted the whole Homeric sentence of dispute. actually, he has now not even incorporated the a part of the sentence that comprises the interpretive challenge. despite the fact that, those Homeric passages had turn into such universal grist for interpreters by way of the fourth century that the quotation of the hole phrases used to be sufficient to speak the total challenge. 30 Homonymy and Amphiboly 29 We take place, in truth, to own Porphyry’s account of Aristotle’s specific solution of this challenge. 31 In that account, the meanings of pl°w are by no means mentioned. as an alternative, Aristotle is worried with distinguishing the that means of the next genitive clause ruled via pl°w. the 2 traces of the Iliad in query are: And now the celebrities had complex, and greater than components of the evening had handed, and a 3rd half nonetheless remained. 32 the matter used to be how greater than components of the evening may possibly cross and nonetheless depart a 3rd but to return. If greater than two-thirds had handed, then there has to be lower than one-third left. The declare of these who learn the only observe pl°wn as ambiguous is that Aristotle solves the difficulty by way of figuring out it to intend “the higher a part of ” instead of “more than. ”33 in line with this answer, Homer potential to claim that the better a part of elements of the evening had handed, whereas one-third of the evening remained. If such have been the matter, Aristotle desire in basic terms have unusual among the 2 homonymous makes use of of pl°wn. yet Aristotle by no means discusses the senses of pl°wn in his unique solution. as a substitute, he spends massive time explaining that tÍn d§o moirºwn refers back to the equivalent halves of the evening instead of to 2 equivalent thirds. This, after all, renders any interpreting of pl°wn as “more than” arithmetically absurd. Now, rather than greater than two-thirds of the evening passing, we've greater than halves of the evening passing! Aristotle’s element is that Homer may well in basic terms have intended that a couple of a part of the 2 equivalent halves had handed. that's, the genitive clause ruled by means of pl°wn needs to be learn distributively, no longer jointly. Translating pl°wn as “the better a part of ” halves is how English marks the genitive clause as distributive instead of collective. “The larger a part of halves” is comparable to “more than one of many halves. ” this isn't an instance of a unmarried homonymous note. relatively, pl°wn, plus a genitive word concerning a numeral, is amphibolous. allow me summarize the following. within the Poetics connection with the Homeric challenge of Iliad 10, 252–53, Aristotle turns out to assert that pl°wn is amphibolous. yet in his targeted answer of that challenge preserved through Porphyry, he by no means discusses pl°wn. as a substitute, he argues that the “two elements” suggest equivalent halves, and that the genitive word ruled by way of pl°wn might be learn both jointly (producing the inconsistency with tr√tath d' ⁄ti moƒra l°leiptai) or distributively (in which case, Homer’s mathematics works out). The amphiboly, then, is the word pl°wn nØx tÍn d§o moirºwn, which Aristotle elliptically marks by way of bringing up the outlet note.

Rated 4.63 of 5 – based on 7 votes